As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases from

FIFA 23: The Greatest Penalty Takers

Who will replace Mark Noble as the best penalty taker in FIFA?

Updated: Sep 26, 2022 7:02 pm

Penalties on FIFA 23 have completely changed, and if you would like to know the best tips on penalties, from a pro, then you can take a look here.

Despite how much penalties have changed this year, it is still important to have a good penalty taker in your squad in FIFA. There is also a room for a newcomer on the list as West Ham United legend Mark Noble has retired.

In FIFA 22 he had the joint highest rated penalties in the game, alongside Wolves forward Raul Jiménez. 

So let’s take a look at the best penalty takers in FIFA 23 and who has replaced Mr West Ham at the very top.

FIFA 23: Top players from the spot

Player  Club Nationality Overall Penalies
Raúl Jiménez Wolverhampton Wanderers  Mexico 82 92
Harry Kane Tottenham Hotspur England 89 92
Mario Balotelli Adana Demirspor Italy 77 91
Max Kruse VfL Wolfsburg Germany 80 91
Andrej Kramaric TSG Hoffenheim Croatia 82 91
Neymar Jr PSG Brazil 89 91
Cristiano Ronaldo Manchester United Portugal 90 90
Olivier Giroud AC Milan France 82 90
Fabinho Liverpool Brazil 87 90
Robert Lewandowski FC Barcelona  Poland 91 90

It may come as a surprise to see Mario Balotelli so close to the top after his fall from grace, but clearly he is still very good from 12 yards. Replacing Noble at the top is Raúl Jiménez as expected.

READ NOW: EA Play trial and Early Access

One thing that is very important with penalty takers is their run up. So definitely try out a variety players before you decide who you want to take your penalties on Ultimate Team. Someone like Neymar Jr. for example, has an incredibly awkward and stuttered run up, the same goes for Paul Pogba.

WePC is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Compare items
  • Total (0)
Shopping cart